Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

Pipo M6 - Speaker Imbalance fix

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

    Pipo M6 - Speaker Imbalance fix

    Shortly after receiving my tablet, it soon became apparent the left speaker was muffled, when compared to the right.

    I became inspired to fix the mechanical imbalances between the speakers, so I decided to dismantle my Pipo M6 with impressive results.



    I was very impressed by the build quality and the branded Sandisk component's.



    Upon closer inspection of the speakers outlets, it became apparent the width of the left channel was noticeably narrower with a wider support bar and square edges.



    Compared to the right with a wider channel and a chamfered edge.



    After reading a Russian translation, I took inspiration to remove both support bars to further enhance the output volume of both speakers.

    Left outlet with a top view of the speaker.



    Right outlet with a side view of the speaker.



    After reinserting the speaker assembly and securing with an additional foam pad on the back of each speaker magnet, the end result is now perfectly balanced and significantly louder with a good mid range.

    Understandably, the sound becomes distorted when the volume is pushed beyond 90% and the speaker cores generated a worryingly large amount of heat.
    Last edited by rceccleston; 03 August 2013, 10:41.

    #2
    This is a very nice result !!! Did you put the foam at the front side of the speaker (between cone and grill) or at the back side (at the "magnet")?

    With what tool did you wide up the channels?

    Reagrds,
    Mischa

    Comment


      #3
      Originally posted by mischa72 View Post
      This is a very nice result !!! Did you put the foam at the front side of the speaker (between cone and grill) or at the back side (at the "magnet")?

      With what tool did you wide up the channels?

      Reagrds,
      Mischa
      After hearing of speaker rattles and seeing the narrow band of glue around the speaker grill, I installed a small piece of M3 pad on the magnet of each speaker.

      Due to the good compression properties of the thin foam pad, the foam pad has compressed when the back of the tablet was reinstalled, holding each speaker in place firmly.

      I used a sharp craft knife to cut through each support bar.

      Comment


        #4
        Originally posted by rceccleston View Post
        After hearing of speaker rattles and seeing the narrow band of glue around the speaker grill, I installed a small piece of M3 pad on the magnet of each speaker.

        Due to the good compression properties of the thin foam pad, the foam pad has compressed when the back of the tablet was reinstalled, holding each speaker in place firmly.

        I used a sharp craft knife to cut through each support bar.
        All clear

        Comment


          #5
          Kudos to rceccleston
          Thanks!!!!!
          Randy
          Freaktab Developer, Product Reviewer, Moderator and "Flashaholic".
          Read my BIO Here
          Be sure to donate to support Freaktab.com. If any of my development work makes a positive difference for you, please make a donation to support future RileyROM's.
          Donate here

          Comment


            #6
            Do you have pictures of the dismantling?

            Regards,
            Mischa

            Comment


              #7
              Originally posted by mischa72 View Post
              Do you have pictures of the dismantling?

              Regards,
              Mischa
              Sorry, I've uploaded all that I took.

              This project was new and fluid since I couldn't find any other guides online.

              Using two credit cards, I started prising the rear case molding off from around the volume switch, working around anti-clockwise to finish in the lower right corner.

              Comment


                #8
                Okay, thanks. Would be almost the same as this movie: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pgJNtTgoJ_I

                Regards,
                Mischa

                Comment


                  #9
                  Originally posted by mischa72 View Post
                  Okay, thanks. Would be almost the same as this movie: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pgJNtTgoJ_I

                  Regards,
                  Mischa
                  Yes, I used the same method as within your video.

                  Comment


                    #10
                    I haven't opened my PIPO yet, but my right speaker broke after 2 weeks. I want to avoid of sending the tablet back to China and pay for the postage an wait for at least a month to get it back.

                    Do you think that it is possible to replace the speaker by myself? Cut the wires, buy a new speaker with similar characteristics and size and solder it?

                    Comment


                      #11
                      Originally posted by peqipex View Post
                      I haven't opened my PIPO yet, but my right speaker broke after 2 weeks. I want to avoid of sending the tablet back to China and pay for the postage an wait for at least a month to get it back.

                      Do you think that it is possible to replace the speaker by myself? Cut the wires, buy a new speaker with similar characteristics and size and solder it?
                      The speaker is a unique shape so maybe hard to source a replacement.

                      Your fault could she either the sound chip, poor soldering or the actual speaker.

                      Considering the speaker did work, its unlikely to be the soldering, since the wiring to well supported.

                      Does the headphone jack work on both channels?

                      Comment


                        #12
                        I also followed the advice on the Russian forum 4pda.ru (I can read in Russian, so that helped), and wrote my own illustrated tutorial, with full resolution photos:

                        Here is my short tutorial on how to fix the low speakers volume (especially for the left speaker) in otherwise superb Ipad-4 resolution tablet Max-M6


                        My mod was a success - the volume became larger, and the left speaker now has the same volume as the right one.

                        Comment


                          #13
                          Great, now we have a black and a white tutorial .

                          Good an clear pics.

                          Comment


                            #14
                            Originally posted by pulsar123 View Post
                            I also followed the advice on the Russian forum 4pda.ru (I can read in Russian, so that helped), and wrote my own illustrated tutorial, with full resolution photos:

                            Here is my short tutorial on how to fix the low speakers volume (especially for the left speaker) in otherwise superb Ipad-4 resolution tablet Max-M6


                            My mod was a success - the volume became larger, and the left speaker now has the same volume as the right one.
                            I did the same thing as in that forum plus I put some foam at bottom edges to prevent sound from dissipating inside. Sound possibly 3x louder.

                            Comment


                              #15
                              Has anyone who did this physical speaker mod tried the newest official ROM from PIPO (July 31; still SDK 1.0)?

                              Apparently, PIPO "addressed" the manufacturing defect with the speaker openings by lowering down the volume of the right speaker, so (1) overall volume became even lower, and (2) for those who did the physical mod, the left speaker became louder.

                              It looks like they will implement this in all the future official ROMs, so we should find a way to revert the balance back.

                              I looked around inside my ROM (which is still Riley 1.3a - the first beta with SDK 2.0), and it looks like this particular configuration file is the one to mess up with when trying to fix the speaker balance:

                              /etc/asound.conf

                              Specifically, the following line:

                              {name 'Speaker Playback Volume' value [31 31]}

                              From the line comment, the range for this parameter is 0...31, so in my ROM both speakers are set at equal and maximum volume setting.

                              I suspect what PIPO "fixed" in the newest official firmware was changing the second number to a lower value.

                              So if your newest ROM will have the left speaker louder, have a look at this file. If the second number is less than 31, you'll have to set both numbers to 31, and save the file and reboot the tablet. (For that, you'll have to remount "/" as read/write first, I believe).

                              I'm gonna give it a try now, to see if it indeed works.

                              EDIT: Actually, no. I changed all the three instances of that line in the file, from 31 31 to 31 0, rebooted, but the balance was the same.

                              I think I'll simply save this, and all other sound related configuration files to my PC. If in a future ROM I'll encounter speaker imbalance, I will diff the old and new files, to see what PIPO did, and will revert that.
                              Last edited by pulsar123; 08 August 2013, 15:48.

                              Comment

                              Working...
                              X